|
Biggedawg gave the name
Join Date: Mar 2004
Location: Las Vegas
Posts: 1,244
|
Lineage controversy
Whether Bischoff had retracted the WCW Championship from the Undisputed Championship or introduced a new championship with a belt that only looks like the WCW Championship belt is a matter of debate among wrestling fans. The WWE's position on the matter has changed over the years, but currently it recognizes the World Heavyweight Championship as being a new title. WWE.com currently lists the title as a new title created in 2002. [1] In mid-2005, WWE.com added a Title History section for the WCW Championship, which listed Chris Jericho as its final champion and may have proven that the current World Heavyweight Championship was a new title. However, the WCW Title History section was removed from WWE.com soon afterwards, causing confusion once again.
The general consensus is that the current World Heavyweight Championship initially claimed legitimacy as the successor to the NWA and WCW belts, but the subtle point has been dropped after the belt gained a reputation of its own. In particular, when Chris Benoit had won the belt at WrestleMania XX, announcers Jim Ross and Jerry Lawler stated that he had won the belt for the first time, despite the fact that Benoit had won the WCW Championship before (in fact, Benoit left WCW while he was champion). To date, only Goldberg, Kurt Angle and Benoit have won both the WCW Championships and World Heavyweight Championships.
While WWE announcers occasionally make allusions to the belt's lineage dating back as far as 1904, a reference to the World Heavyweight Championship held by Georg Hackenschmidt, as well as segments detailing the history linking that timeframe as well as the WCW lineage to the title during episodes of WWE Confidential, the majority of evidence suggests that the belt does not derive its lineage beyond its debut on September 2, 2002, and instead is simply using the WCW World Heavyweight Championship belt to represent the new title. In particular, former WCW Champions -- even those such as Kurt Angle who had won the belt during the Invasion storyline -- were, with the exception of Goldberg and Benoit and more recently Kurt Angle, never recognized as having held the current World Heavyweight Championship belt. However recently on SmackDown!, Angle stated he was a "6-time world champion" thus making a similar claim to Flair including his WCW reign.
Perhaps most telling of how the World Heavyweight Championship is considered a new belt (and perhaps subtly that the WCW championship was not a major championship in post-Brand Extension WWE, but that it is included in world title histories for some wrestlers (i.e. Ric Flair and Hulk Hogan were both listed as former WCW champions during the 2002 Brand Extension in the stats given for them when the initial draft took place)) was on the May 19, 2003 edition of RAW, when Stone Cold Steve Austin gave Triple H the choice to defend the title against any former "world champion" on the roster and specifically named all of RAW's former WWE champions -- Chris Jericho, Shawn Michaels, Kane, Kevin Nash -- and then named Booker T, Scott Steiner, and Goldberg, all of whom were former WCW Champions but had never won a world title in WWE.
It is to be noted, however, legends such as Ric Flair have their major wrestling title totals, including the WCW championship, amalgamated - thus he is considered to be a sixteen-time world champion despite the fact that he had never held the World Heavyweight Championship (although he was a six-time WCW champion and two-time WWE champion).
Despite WWE's claims, some fans still claim that the NWA and WCW Championships have carried on in the World Heavyweight Championship, citing the restoration of the WWE United States Championship and the WWE Cruiserweight Championship as examples. In the case of the former, it was reintroduced as a WWE belt while retaining its NWA and WCW heritage despite having it absorbed into the WWE Intercontinental Championship (and ultimately, the World Heavyweight Championship) and a subsequent two-year absence. In addition, Batista, in his speech before vacating the championship, cited Dusty Rhodes, Harley Race, and Ric Flair as former World Heavyweight Champions, despite none of them having won the belt (Rhodes and Race never won the WWE Championship either, but all three were former holders of the NWA World Heavyweight Championship, and Flair is a 16-time champion, including two WWE Championship reigns), giving some credence to its possible NWA roots.
Some fans also claim that WWE's view on its own title histories (and thus lineage) may be susceptible to revisionism: such revisionism would explain how the WWE recognized The Fabulous Moolah holding the WWE Women's Championship for over 30 years (it actually was inactive for much of that period) or how WWE does not recognize the WWF Light Heavyweight Championship's lineage history before it was awarded to Taka Michinoku, despite the fact that it had been defended before as part of the J-Crown. Interestingly, WWE.com's profile of Chris Benoit seemed to support this, which mentioned he previously won the World Heavyweight Championship while in WCW shortly after winning his "first" World Heavyweight Championship at WrestleMania XX (Although WWE.com recognises Ric Flair as a former WCW Champion, but for some reason not Benoit who was referred to as a former World Heavyweight Champion.). This supposed bias on the part of WWE, however, is also used in defense of the view that the WCW Championship being not considered to be a major championship (save for cases such as Flair above), only reaching "major status" as the World Heavyweight Championship, as WWE notes the WCW championships of different wrestlers on an inconsistent basis, mentioning it for some champions (such as Chris Jericho) but not for others (such as Kurt Angle).
Any question of the true lineage of the WWE World Heavyweight Championship was complicated on the January 13, 2006 edition of WWE Friday Night SmackDown!. When Batista dropped the title on that day due to injury, he included Dusty Rhodes in a short list of previous holders of the title. Dusty Rhodes was a holder of the NWA World Heavyweight Championship, but never held a singles title in WWE. In addition, though he has held the WWE Championship before, Ric Flair has not held the "Big Gold Belt" in WWE. This could be the first on-screen acknowledgement of a connection between the lineages of the WCW and WWE versions of the "Big Gold Belt". A brief recap of this event the on January 21, 2006, SmackDown! also displayed the WCW version of the "Big Gold Belt" when General Manager Theodore Long referred to the heritage of the title.
On February 27, 2006, WWE.com added a section devoted to Triple H's 10 World Title reigns[2]. The section devoted to his sixth title reign[3](the one awarded to him by then-General Manager of RAW Eric Bischoff) states that "RAW General Manager Eric Bischoff then declared that since Lesnar had left for SmackDown that RAW needed its own champion. So with that, he opened a briefcase and pulled out the old WCW Championship and gave it to Triple H, naming him the first World Heavyweight Champion."
__________________
And I do crimes, for the bread like croutons
With two nines, I be laying clowns down like futons
With the the bullets and the rocket, my pockets are swoll of cream
My bullets scream, keep the steel in my hands like Wolverine-Cassidy
CCC CCC C-UNOT!
www.myspace.com/manofdestiny
|