|
Ed Lake: Wow. I totally thought this was just a love story at first... then the last two lines really brought it all around. Man, there's sooooo much in there foreshadowing it subtly. This was superbly done, because the foreshadowing agents don't call attention to themselves, and with how many god/heaven-ish references there are, that's a damned good job. I liked how you broke up the rhyme scheme in a few places, just a slight switch up to abba, with the inside lines shorter, so it didn't affect the rhythm of the whole piece, just a slight stutter step. Very very nice piece.
Nique: I liked the line:
Almost fall from the sickness from the cost of bottle prescriptions..
quite a bit... like the idea that getting loans and shit for school, yet having to pay exorbitant fees for medicine actually making you feel more sick than before...
But again I keep seeing a whole bunch of small mistakes... like in line 3, was should be were and should put force in the past tense, then it's not your apartment tenants, because that would mean you're the landlord in the phrasing... it'd be the your apartment's other tenants... then some phrasing is just bad, like, law and amendments.. well, the amendments are either things you are allowed to do, or not allowed to do by the law, ie, laws. then tow trucking business... who says that? It's just a tow truck... the diction and syntax is forced like that in more than just a few places for the rhyme's sake... prices and gallons... we're not waiting for prices AND gallons to go down, it's the prices OF gallons. if the gallons go down, it's another oil crisis, and the prices skyrocket... or needing accompany- needing some company maybe, but you can't need accompany, that's just not how the word works.
Vote: ALthough Nique had some nice points in her topical, this was lacking polish, a lot of the rhymes seemed forced, sacrificing continuity, surfacing maloprops, and bringing down the piece from a writer's perspective. Ed Lake's story was subtle, and very well done, very polished, and took on a whole new life with the twist. I'm going with Ed Lake.
__________________
-- -- -- --
"Those who know they are profound strive for clarity. Those who would like to seem profound strive for obscurity." -Nietzsche
-- -- -- -- -- --
This isn't a place for people to improve. This is a support group, where everybody just pats each other on the back and give words of encouragement. -predicate on the poetry realm
|