|
Michael Clayton of Text
Join Date: Nov 2001
Location: Atlanta, Ga
Posts: 19,097
|
Lucifa, i actually quite enjoyed this, story wise i think this was interesting and entertaining, kept me reading the entire time, i liked the structure being that it was similar to mine in recent weeks but there were many hiccups in the flow, all of which were minor distractions to the content but nevertheless they were distracting and so i thought it only right to mention them, times like the gaze/chauffeur just threw me off a bit because you would be rhyming about 3/4 syllables (give or take) and then throw in a line like that where only the last syllable would rhyme, other lines were just imperfect rhymes but i easily kept reading like trigger/finger, hardly a distraction but noticeable, aside from these which did little damage negatively towards the verse i actually enjoyed the story, somewhat fast paced, i had no idea how it would be related to your situation but the ending was spot on for me, i was confused at first thinking that maybe you revealed that it was a split personality or something but then i realized that it was you torturing someone who had threatened your son, very evil in nature but nicely done, of course you could have done so much more with this but you covered a lot of important aspects of the story, from the crash to the kidnapping to the person waking up and seeing his mom and other tiny bits and pieces that made this more complete, i don't know what else to say, i liked it though for what its worth though against any good story with strong mechanics it would probably fail because something didn't click to me (but i can't put my finger on it), all in all though it was pretty good from where i'm sitting, oh and the car lights drive by was a nice touch (just to irk GL?), he's being too picky where it isn't needed, if you read the line you're describing how it would have seemed had you been there, darkness and all you see is the car lights instead of the car, very precise, both clatter silently and shoot sharp in pain were stretches though but still minor and easily overlooked, like clatter i suppose isn't necessarily loud but naturally we use it in the sense of noise and thus it seems forced, i'm sure if i were to thoroughly analyze this i'm sure i'd find other faults but oh well
saga, i assume by scared you really meant scarred, simple mistake i suppose, the intro was a bit iffy, i liked the buffet of emptiness and the rope image and whatnot, but i didn't like the structure here for your big introduction, overall i think it failed to serve its purpose due to the structure you chose and it only being good in the beginning, after this it picked up quite a bit but your main flow was your choice in content, i really expected so much from you after last week but now i'm concerned that either it was a fluke or i was just tripping and overrated you as a writer, nevertheless i thought this was boring in content, very played material here unworthy of a verse really and the way you presented it was nothing new, i liked some of the descriptions and stuff in the middle but its like you repeated yourself after you already said that she was murdered as if it was just a side event but then later turned your focus back to it as if it were the main event, plus again (to repeat myself in saga fashion) the whole drug bit was a bit redundant and you really didn't pull it off here, decent tie in to the quote though which i can clearly tell inspired you to write such a piece but you should have known that this would be seen as drab, drug pieces at least have to be original in approach or do something creatively (like infinite's last week) to be taken seriously, this was good at times but overall pointless because you did little with an already overused subject and i just couldn't get into it, also you suffered mechanically like the intro, directly after the intro, and the ending, the bulk of it went along nicely for the most part but offered nothing new to the reader, i almost felt cheated
all in all i think i liked luci's and though i can't say that saga's was terrible (although he definitely had mechanical flaws as well and the intro was a bit eh) his choice of material was the dead giveaway
lucifa wins
__________________
.textmastersoftheuniverse.
calefaction lucifa thereturn alias2 magus quriosity
speedycalhoun johndough bonniebathory metasin sephiroth
((JOIN THE RBL NOW))
►► CLICK ME, CLICK ME ◄◄
|