Atheist - Great story bro. It had a real down to earth vibe to it which I always dig. I didn't really see what 3 PA was talkin' about, the story seemed pretty straight foward to me, though I've never been one for intricacies (sp?), if you did write with the intention 3 PA says, I really would like you to break it down for me so I know how to connect with you stories in the future. Not saying I didn't with this one, because I definitely did. The way you ended it I thought was great, no fairy tales or nothin', just a girl that lives an incredibly shitty life which never really stops being shitty. I liked how you broke down everything to, you went into the fathers emotions very intimately after the death of the mother, and that was probably my favorite part of the verse. As far as mechanics are concerned, idk, it's hard for me to apply my standard of mechanics to writers like you, because you don't write in rap format. I mean, it flowed smoothely, and the rhyme scheme was pretty good, kinda off sometimes, but on most of the time. However, I don't know how you would perform this to a beat. Great piece of text though, really enjoyed the piece and the linear progression of it.
_KDP_ - Really dope. Honestly, I really didn't see where this was goin' until like 16 lines in, but once the concept became clear, it really drew me in. The only thing I didn't really like was the wording, your wording was reaaally bad in some parts, like
Quote:
finish tape visualized, but disappears soon as it comes into view.
That’s what it told me, this mystic vision that would come in my snooze,
|
but when it was also fuckin' sick some parts, like
Quote:
as we waded through swamp in constant search of higher ground
waters rose as thunderous downpours roared enlightened sounds
|
I feel like you sacrafice your wording for rhyme scheme sometimes, and ya know what, sometimes it's better just use one rhyme syllable and go with the better wording. That said, your rhyme scheme was pretty fuckin' good. Your flow wasn't as good as I saw the past couple of weeks though, it seemed a lot more stretched this week. I really liked the way it ended, it really brought everything together.
Vote - Atheist, he just wrote the better story and wrote it better. TRY HARDER KDP! You coulda won if you sat down and developed you verse more...