|
the intellectual.
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: 'in' the world, not 'of' the world. a slave to a page on my wordpad. 2X RSTL Champion. 3X RBL Champion.
Posts: 650
|
well, i had already broken this down and i am pissed to have to start over, nevertheless this is a good enough match and more than warrants my opinion so i feel its only right to type it all over again, sorry if its shorter than original but i usually write my votes as i read and therefore i tend to point out more stuff
saga, first and foremost this was good, i dug it thoroughly, rhythmic pattern was thorough yet friendly, the descriptions were good, and what i enjoyed most is that you actually delved into the characters and the reasoning behind the events that were to come without losing the attention of the reader, that in itself is impressive, more notable however is that you did this all without seeming too lengthy, though the verse was clearly long it was more than worth it, initially i would have said this started slow and it actually did but only because i was unaware of what was really going on, the entire verse really went under the radar for me and this is mainly why i feel it was so impressive, it wasn't until after i read the entire verse that it clicked and then i re-read the topics and the opener and was literally like, "damn".. dope verse nonetheless, you tackled both topics tremendously well and odd topics they were and though the story itself was somewhat simplistic in concept i don't think i would have thunk it or delivered it the same and in such a good fashion as you did here, i really got into the occurrences and reasons behind them and come the end i was originally thinking, "okay, he lost it" but it actually added up so nicely and you delivered the ending so smoothly and then i thought "well, maybe i missed something" because the story was weird but once i realized the topics chosen this was golden, i think i'm repeating myself and/or giving you too much praise so let me move on to another subject, the tone was spot on and though it was obvious that the narrator was not an actual character it fit perfectly in being very mature but never over the top, it was exactly what you would expect from an educated character going through the pains that he did, overall this was a well mapped story with a good flow and a fitting tone and ending, what more could you ask for?, not the best by far because there have been many great stories but what a good first impression, i could definitely see you champing the league if you could actually stay consistent and interesting in your characters and the events that occur
vern, wow, great to see you back to old fashion, nevertheless you still have numerous typos which is less distracting than that of a RICO or DAD verse meaning that yours are only minor such as misspellings and whatnot, things that don't actually hinder the rhythm of reading because i can glance and know what you meant however my OSD allows me to catch such minimal mistakes, anyway.. the story (well, it was hardly a story) was good nonetheless but i honestly can't see how this would rival that of your opponents, a classic story versus topical here in which the topical is obviously prevailing but honestly while i think you did a great job i did find faults and the largest of them all is the fact that this is only a rehashed subject presented with a flawless flow and in blue fonts, not to be rude or disrespectful to a great because time and time again i have noted that i have always admired your talents but this was literally just an overused concept flipped in a great manner, not great enough to topple an original story though that could almost match your flow and was much more fulfilling and entertaining for a read, i did enjoy this and enjoyed it much but it hardly offered anything new to me, the face the proof line lost it for me which was quite possibly the only hiccup mechanically besides minor flaws in spelling and whatnot, and the topical was delivered with very high standards, but i just wouldn't rate this higher than saga's
overall, this was the best match thus far, i thoroughly enjoyed both sides but saga's just captivated me more and it felt as though i had read a good book, i tend to overprop people when i like a certain story especially the first good piece of the week that i have read so please don't take my ranting to the head, this was good but also beatable (as proven in this thread alone), but the only gripe i found with saga's imo was the fact that it was long (though i think this was actually positive because it didn't see to drag and was never really dull) and while looking back i actually couldn't find the correlation between the victimless crime topic, the only thing i could think of is that the body was somehow chemically disposed of but then i couldn't see Winston in a prison for only believing he killed some woman that hypothetically didn't exist, maybe an insane asylum or some sort of nut house but that part didn't really add up, at the same time Vern's piece was dope but not only do i prefer stories to topicals but i don't feel as though conceptually this was fresh, quite possibly one of the best takes on the topic but i believe i was most captivated by flow rather than content and to me saga's flow was damn near just as good and his content caught my attention, also Vern's piece felt somewhat brief compared to the thoroughness of Saga's, that and Vern just hop scotched through random metaphors and whatnot (which was a good touch, but quit common in topicals), i don't know.. i think i'm rambling so..
saga wins it for me
lol, i had to edit this in.. but i think i'm tripping, this shit was long as fuck but only took me like 10 minutes to type, i think i got carried away because i type at like 80-90 wpm and i had already read the material
__________________
Don't Worry If I Write Checks,
EYE RITE RIMES
T E X T M A S T E R O F T H E U N I V E R S E
The World-Renowned Author
Last edited by Eye-Rime; 08-03-2008 at 09:39 PM.
|